November 10, 2026

Sisters Rental Market: October 2026

Sisters Oregon Rental Market Report · October 2026

Monthly market report from Legacy Property Management


The Bottom Line: The Sisters rental market in October 2026 looked wild on paper and calm in practice. Zillow's average house rent jumped to $3,900 for the month, then fell straight back to $2,765 by November 1. Nothing about rents changed. A handful of very expensive listings came and went. The real story is slower: 17 houses are listed, the most we have tracked, and they have been on the market an average of 85 days. Tenants on existing leases are paying about $2,520.

For small landlords, Sisters is paying you for keeping tenants, not for raising rent. Renew the good ones at modest increases, price any vacancy close to what houses lease for, and hold what you own. And keep one eye on the long game: in October the city and county approved a 319-acre expansion of the town's growth boundary.

Sisters Oregon single-family rental market scorecard for October 2026 showing 2,765 dollar average asking rent, 85 days on market, 17 available houses, and 1,445 inventory-days

Sisters Rental Market October 2026: What Rent Actually Did

If you only read one number about the Sisters rental market in October 2026, make it this one: the average house was asking $2,765 a month on November 1. That is $65 (2.4%) above September's $2,700 and $35 (1.3%) below the same point last year. In other words, asking rents are flat.

You may have seen a very different number. For most of October, Zillow showed the average Sisters house at $3,900, a jump of $1,200 in a single month. In our September Sisters rental market report we said that figure was not a rent spike, just a reflection of which houses happened to be listed. Four weeks later it dropped by $1,135 and landed almost exactly where it started. We are treating October's $3,900 as noise and using the November 1 reading as the honest picture of where the market stands.

Line chart of Sisters Oregon house asking rent by month for 2025 and 2026, showing the October 2026 average of 3,900 dollars as a listing-mix distortion and the November 1 reading back at 2,765 dollars, above in-place rent near 2,520 dollars

Step back and the year looks steady. Sisters house rents have spent nearly all of 2026 between about $2,500 and $2,800. A year ago, rents dipped to roughly $2,525 in October and then settled at $2,800 for November and December. This year the market is entering winter at about the same level, a touch lower.

One caution we repeat every month: Sisters is small. With 17 houses listed, one or two properties can move the average by hundreds of dollars. We only call something a trend when a second measure agrees with it. This month nothing points to rising rents. The asking average is flat, days on market are flat, and the number of houses for rent went up.

What changed since last month

MeasureLast monthThis monthChange
Average asking rent, houses$2,700 (September)$2,765 (November 1)+$65, +2.4%
Average days on market, current listings84 (October 5)85 (November 1)+1 day
Houses listed for rent1517+2
Inventory-days1,2601,445+14.7%
30-year mortgage rate7.40% (October 8)7.18% (November 5)-0.22 points
Monthly cost to own minus cost to rent$1,890$1,740-$150

Why the $3,900 Disappeared

An average only tells you about the houses in it. In early October, more than half of the houses listed around Sisters were asking roughly $3,400 or more, and one was asking $12,500. The homes priced near the local norm had already leased, so the expensive ones were most of what was left.

By November 1 that had reversed. The most expensive listing is now $4,500. Houses asking about $3,400 and up fell from 56% of the market to about a third, and more than four in ten listings now ask less than $2,700. The middle of the market, the typical house, is priced around $2,700 to $2,800, right in line with the average. That makes $2,765 a number you can actually price against again.

Bar chart of Sisters Oregon rental house listings by asking-rent band on October 5 and November 1, 2026, showing listings at about 3,400 dollars and up falling from 56 percent to 33 percent of the market

The practical lesson: when you see a big monthly swing in a Sisters rent average, check what is listed before you change your own price. The high-end listings that pushed October up did not set a new market. They simply left.

Supply: More Houses, Same Long Wait

On November 1 there were 17 houses listed for rent around Sisters, up from 15 on October 5 and 11 on September 1. Current listings have been on the market an average of 85 days, essentially unchanged from 84 a month earlier. That is nearly three months, and it is about four weeks longer than Bend or Redmond.

We also track inventory-days, which multiplies the number of houses listed by how long they have been sitting. It is the best single read on total supply waiting for a tenant. That figure rose to 1,445, up about 15% in a month and the highest of the five readings we have taken since June. Through late summer the supply in Sisters was turning over without growing. In October it grew.

Three bar charts of Sisters Oregon rental supply across five 2026 snapshots showing 17 houses listed, 85 average days on market, and 1,445 inventory-days on November 1

We do not publish a vacancy percentage for Sisters. The town has so few rental houses that any percentage would carry more error than information, and Zillow's Sisters search reaches past the city limits. The raw count and the days on market are the honest gauges. Right now they say the same thing: a landlord bringing a house to market in November is competing with more listings than at any point since we began tracking in June, heading into the slowest leasing months.

What Sisters Tenants Actually Pay

Asking rent is what landlords hope for. In-place rent is what tenants are paying today on existing leases. Across the roughly 190 Sisters houses we now track, in-place rent averaged about $2,520 in late October. Three-bedroom houses averaged close to $2,600.

If you read last month's report, you will notice that is lower than the $2,590 we cited then. The difference is the size of the group: we now track nearly four times as many houses, and the broader group runs a little cheaper. The two figures are not comparable, so do not read the lower number as rents falling.

That leaves a gap of about $250, or 10%, between what landlords ask and what current tenants pay. In a tight market, that gap is rent waiting to be captured at turnover. In this one, with listings sitting 85 days, it reads more like asking prices that tenants are not meeting. A house priced closer to $2,550 to $2,650 that leases in a month will usually out-earn one priced at $2,800 that sits for three.

How long tenants stay

Sisters tenants stay about three years on average. Census data shows more than four in ten renter households in the Sisters ZIP code moved in before 2020, and local apartment renewal rates near two-thirds point to the same three-year rhythm. With an 85-day average on the market, every turnover can cost close to three months of rent before cleaning and repairs. Keeping a good tenant is worth far more than an extra $100 a month.

Who can afford a Sisters house

A $2,765 rent takes a bit more than a third of the median household income in Sisters, which Census data puts near $94,500. To qualify comfortably, a household needs roughly $100,000 to $110,000 a year. The typical renter household around Sisters earns less than half of that, so demand for houses comes mostly from newcomers and from would-be buyers who are waiting. Our own movers data shows people arriving with a median income near $109,000, only slightly above those leaving, and a median age in the mid-50s. Demand is steady. It is not getting richer, which is why rents keep bumping into a ceiling.

Apartments: The Cheaper Option Is Getting Cheaper

Sisters apartment tenants are paying about $1,765 a month on existing leases, slightly less than a year ago. Asking rents on vacant apartments have fallen by double digits over the past year, occupancy has slipped in recent months, and apartments that leased lately took around 100 days to fill. Sisters has only a few apartment communities, so treat those as direction rather than precise readings.

The direction matters for house landlords. A house now rents for about $1,000 more than an apartment, a premium of more than 50%. When the cheaper option is discounting, some house tenants on tight budgets will trade down, and that puts a soft cap on how hard you can push a renewal. Sisters is not alone in this. In Redmond, 149 apartments in the group we track are listed with no signed lease and communities are offering as much as four to six weeks of free rent this winter, and in Bend the average rent at large apartment complexes is slightly below where it was a year ago. More choice is coming too: Trinity Place's 40 workforce apartments are scheduled to begin leasing in spring 2027.

How Sisters Compares With Bend and Redmond

All three Central Oregon markets told a version of the same story this month: a noisy headline, and flat rents underneath it.

In Bend, the average house rent slipped to $2,995 in October, down 3.4% from September, and was at $2,895 by November 1. Bend has 262 houses listed, the most we have tracked there, and total supply waiting for a tenant grew about 18% in a month, a little more than the 15% in Sisters. In Redmond, October's average jumped to $2,650 because of which houses were listed, then returned to $2,495 by November 1, with supply steady at 45 houses. Measured the same way on November 1, asking rents are 2.7% below a year ago in Bend, 1.3% below in Sisters, and 4.0% above in Redmond. You can read the detail in our Bend rental market report for October 2026 and our Redmond rental market report for October 2026.

Bar charts comparing Bend, Redmond, and Sisters Oregon house rentals on November 1, 2026: asking rent of 2,895, 2,495, and 2,765 dollars, in-place rent, and days on market of 57, 60, and 85

The gap between what landlords ask and what current tenants pay lines up across the region as well. On November 1, existing tenants were paying about 4% less than the asking average in Bend, down from about 7% on October's average, and roughly 9% to 10% less in both Redmond and Sisters. None of the three markets has a large reserve of rent waiting to be captured at turnover.

Sisters sits between the two on price. Its houses ask about $130 less than Bend's and $270 more than Redmond's. What sets Sisters apart is time. Listings in Bend and Redmond have been on the market about 57 to 60 days. In Sisters it is 85. Sisters also has the fastest population growth of the three, about 1.9% in the latest Portland State University estimates, yet the slowest leasing. The reason is who is arriving. Many newcomers are older and are buying, not renting, so strong growth does not translate into a long line of tenants.

The backdrop for all three is healthy. Deschutes County unemployment was 3.9% in September, a preliminary figure, well below Oregon's 5.0%, and the number of employed residents was up about 1.1% from a year earlier. People have jobs. They are just being careful about what they pay for housing.

Owning vs Renting, and the For-Sale Market

Mortgage rates came off their peak. Freddie Mac's weekly survey put the 30-year fixed rate at 7.40% in mid-October, the highest in almost three years, and it has eased for three straight weeks to 7.18% on November 5. October still averaged 7.33%, up from 6.86% in September.

At 7.18%, owning the median Sisters home costs about $4,505 a month with 20% down, taxes, and basic insurance. Renting the average house costs $2,765. That is a gap of roughly $1,740 a month in favor of renting, down from $1,890 a month ago but still very wide. As long as that gap holds, many would-be buyers stay renters, which supports demand for houses even while leasing is slow. It is in the same range as Bend, where our October report put the gap near $1,620 a month, and roughly three times Redmond's, which is about $550. If mortgage rates keep falling, Redmond tenants will be the first who can afford to buy. Bend and Sisters tenants will be the last.

Bar chart comparing the monthly cost to own the median Sisters Oregon home with the average house rent, showing a gap of 1,890 dollars in early October and 1,740 dollars in early November 2026

It also means buying a rental with a loan still does not work on paper. A $2,765 rent on a $710,000 house is a gross yield of about 4.7% before a single expense, well under the cost of the mortgage.

Our home sales figures are unchanged since the last report, because the next round of sales data has not been published yet. The median Sisters house sold for about $710,000 over July through September, down 4.4% from a year earlier. September alone closed eight sales at a median of $735,000, and those homes took a median of 57 days to sell. Inventory sits near five months, a balanced market that is neither a clear time to sell nor a bargain window to buy.

Bonus Metric: Sisters Made Room to Grow

The number that matters most for the long term this month is 319 acres. On October 14 the Sisters City Council voted unanimously to add roughly that much land to the town's urban growth boundary, northeast of town between Highway 126 and Sisters Eagle Airport. On October 22 the Deschutes County commissioners approved it as well. The plan now goes to the state for acknowledgment. The city has details on its urban growth boundary page.

Chart of Sisters Oregon population growth from 2,691 in 2018 to a forecast 5,169 in 2043, with 319 acres added to the urban growth boundary, 67 single-family permits in 2026, and no short-term rentals allowed in the expansion area

Nothing gets built there soon. After the state signs off, the land still has to be annexed, planned, and served with roads and utilities, so new homes are years away. But three things are worth knowing now.

First, Sisters is already building. The city permitted 67 new single-family homes in the first nine months of 2026, which is about 4% of the town's housing stock in under a year. Most will be sold, not rented, but every new home gives a renter one more way to become an owner. Across Deschutes County, single-family permits are up about 24% over the past 12 months while apartment permits are down about 30%.

Second, the city's own vision work expects the population to roughly double from its 2018 level by 2043. The expansion is how that growth gets housed.

Third, and most relevant to landlords: city rules prohibit short-term rentals in growth boundary expansion areas. Homes built there cannot become vacation rentals. Over time that means more of Sisters' new housing will be lived in year-round or rented long-term, which is good for tenants and adds competition for existing rental houses. The scarcity that has supported Sisters rents will ease slowly, not suddenly.

Two housekeeping items. Oregon's rent increase cap for 2027 is 10%, and homes less than 15 years old are exempt, which covers a lot of Sisters. With rents flat, the cap is not what limits you here. The market is. And the state's wildfire-season pause on insurance cancellations and non-renewals in evacuation ZIP codes, including Sisters, was scheduled to run through October 29. If your policy renews this winter, call your agent now so you are not surprised.

Why This Matters for Sisters Landlords

Put the pieces together and Sisters is a market that rewards patience and punishes overpricing. Asking rents have not risen in a year. Tenants in place are paying about $2,520. Listed houses wait nearly three months. Apartments are getting cheaper, more houses are listed than at any point since June, and the town just cleared the way for long-term growth.

The good news is real too. Owning still costs about $1,740 a month more than renting, so the pool of people who need a rental house is not shrinking. The local job market is strong. And tenants here tend to stay about three years.

The math that matters: at $2,765 a month, an 85-day vacancy costs about $7,700 in lost rent. Pricing a house $150 below the average costs $1,800 over a full year. In Sisters this winter, the lower price is almost always the better deal.

MoveWhat to doWhy it works this month
Renew earlyOffer good tenants a renewal now with a modest increase of 2% to 4%.Asking rents are flat and a turnover can cost three months of rent.
Price to leaseList vacancies between about $2,550 and $2,750 for a typical three-bedroom, not at the top of the range.Seventeen houses are competing and the mid-priced ones are the ones leasing.
Ignore the headlineCheck what is listed before reacting to a big monthly swing in the average.October's $3,900 came and went in four weeks without any change in real rents.
Hold, don't lever upKeep houses with low-rate loans. Skip new purchases that need a 7% mortgage.Gross yield is about 4.7% and owning costs $1,740 a month more than renting.
Plan for more supplyBudget for upkeep and upgrades that keep your house competitive over the next five years.The growth boundary expansion and steady permits mean more year-round housing is coming.

Wondering what your Sisters rental should rent for this winter, or whether to renew or re-list? Legacy Property Management is a boutique property management company in Bend serving Sisters rental owners. Get in touch and we will give you a straight answer based on what houses are actually leasing for.

Contact Us

Let's Discuss Your Property Needs

Co owners of Legacy Property management Steven Kaufman and Kolby Knickerbocker

OWNERS & PROPERTY MANAGERS

Steven Kaufman and Kolby Knickerbocker
info@legacypropertymanagement.com
(541) 508 5815

Scroll to Top